- D3Playbook
- Posts
- The NCAA's Eligibility Rules May Be In Serious Legal Trouble. Here's Why
The NCAA's Eligibility Rules May Be In Serious Legal Trouble. Here's Why
There’s a common saying in the legal profession: bad facts make bad law.


MARCH 6, 2025 | composed by STEVE ULRICH
What administrators, coaches and fans are reading. #whyD3
Send tips to [email protected] and/or via DM
😎 It’s Thursday. Make it a great one.
Headlines
📜 Could NCAA’s Eligibility Rules Be In Legal Trouble?
🏒 Conference Championship Weekend
🏆️ Lost History of the Lambert Trophy, Bowl and Cup
🏀 DIII March Madness
🎶 Your Morning Starter. Everybody Needs Someone to Love, The Blues Brothers
📰 Help Support Our Work. Subscribe to D3Playbook for winter championship season or for the spring semester. We appreciate your support.
TOP STORY
1. The NCAA's Eligibility Rules May Be In Serious Legal Trouble. Here's Why

by Sam Ehrlich, Extra Points
“By now, anyone connected to college sports knows the NCAA is facing serious legal challenges. Beyond the lawsuits tied to the House settlement and the Johnson wage-and-hour employment case, the NCAA has recently been hit with multiple lawsuits targeting its athlete eligibility rules. These cases stem from December’s Diego Pavia decision, where Judge William L. Campbell ruled that Pavia’s JUCO years shouldn’t count against his NCAA eligibility.
In the weeks following that decision, the NCAA was forced to issue a blanket waiver allowing an extra year to fellow ex-JUCO players set to exhaust their eligibility this year in an attempt to avoid a flood of copycat cases. Even so, four new “Pavia-like” cases have been filed by ex-JUCO baseball players who slipped through the cracks of the Pavia waiver as they exhausted their Division I eligibility last year.

Subscribe to Individual Package to read the rest.
Become a paying subscriber of Individual Package to get access to this post and other subscriber-only content.
Already a paying subscriber? Sign In.
A subscription gets you:
- • Five newsletters a week
- • Access to interviews with decision-makers in DIII
- • Access to the D3Podcast
Reply